Authority and Expertise in Ancient Scientific Culture by Jason König, Greg Woolf PDF

By Jason König, Greg Woolf

How did historical medical and knowledge-ordering writers make their paintings authoritative? This booklet solutions that question for a variety of old disciplines, from arithmetic, medication, structure and agriculture, via to legislations, historiography and philosophy - focusing usually, yet no longer completely, at the literature of the Roman Empire. It attracts consciousness to conduct that those varied fields had in universal, whereas additionally displaying how person texts and authors manipulated average ideas of self-authorisation in exact methods. It stresses the significance of aggressive and assertive sorts of self-presentation, and in addition examines the various pressures that pulled within the wrong way by way of taking a look at authors who selected to recognize the restrictions in their personal wisdom or resisted shut id with slim models of professional identification. a last bankruptcy through Sir Geoffrey Lloyd deals a comparative account of clinical authority and services in historic chinese language, Indian and Mesopotamian culture.

"A significant strand of modern ancient-science scholarship has given prominence to questions on how old scientists represented themselves and their disciplines, and especially how they made their writings authoritative. /.../ historical specialists needed to paintings a lot tougher than their glossy opposite numbers to persuade their audiences and capability consumers and scholars, by way of rhetorical skill, in their competence, and so tended to arrive for selfassertive and ostentatiously leading edge first-person personas. In that feel realization to personality and authority may be an excellent extra visible precedence for the traditional international than for contemporary technology, on condition that the clinical ‘I’ used to be frequently much more famous. There at the moment are many guides which pay critical realization to those concerns for particular texts and authors. The paintings of Galen, the good clinical author of the second one century CE, is an seen instance. the extreme variety of his surviving works and the prominence of his personal character in lots of of his writings make him a fantastic candidate for viewing old clinical self-assertion in motion. And in lots of respects his paintings is average of historic scientificwritingmore broadly.He offers a fashionable function tohis personal personality. he's continuously aggressive: he usually debunks rival practitioners and rival disciplines which don't degree as much as the philosophically encouraged clinical wisdom he himself espouses. He attracts cognizance to his personal ethical advantage in methods which carry an effect of reliability. He additionally attracts awareness to his remarkably huge studying. His authority rests partly on his complicated wisdom of the paintings of his predecessors, and his alignment of himselfwith that culture, specially in his opportunistic appropriation of the writings of the Hippocratic corpus so they come to check his personal clinical perspectives. even as he again and again demanding situations acquired knowledge. on occasion, he does that via a declare to non-public adventure and statement, for instance in his widespread narration of incidents from his vast medical adventure and in his widespread money owed of experimentation at the our bodies of animals (in a few instances performed in entrance of an viewers, in a manner which permits him to delight in public refutation and humiliation of his poorly trained rivals). He additionally time and again attracts attentiontothe complexity of themedical expertisewhichhe espouses,writing at size at the numerous subdivisions of the paintings of medication, after which in flip subdividing, in significantly advanced methods, some of the subdisciplines of scientific wisdom, to be able to go away a magnificent experience of his command over a really subtle physique of knowledge.9 Many different authors too have started to be analysed for his or her use of those and different comparable recommendations of self-presentation, no matter if there are few different authors who use them something like so richly and forcefully as Galen. certainly one of our arguments during this quantity, although, is that much more has to be performed to appreciate the connections among various our bodies of workmanship and diverse authors of their recommendations of self-authorisation."

Show description

Read or Download Authority and Expertise in Ancient Scientific Culture PDF

Similar science & medicine books

Download e-book for iPad: Theoretical Roots of US Foreign Policy: Machiavelli and by Thomas M. Kane

This quantity explores the explanations why American leaders from the 1700s onwards often undertake rules of unilateralism. Thomas M. Kane offers clean factors for America’s invasion of Iraq and defiance of foreign agreements, which cross a lot deeper than traditional evaluations of specific presidents to ascertain the genuine value of the September eleven assaults.

The Ascent of Chiefs: Cahokia and Mississippian Politics in - download pdf or read online

This formidable ebook offers a theoretical rationalization of the way prehistoric Cahokia grew to become a stratified society, and eventually the head of local American cultural success north of Mexico. contemplating Cahokia when it comes to category fight, Pauketat claims that the political consolidation during this quarter of the Mississippi Valley occurred particularly without notice, round A.

Read e-book online Unconscious Crime: Mental Absence and Criminal PDF

A sleepwalking, homicidal nursemaid; a "morally vacant" juvenile poisoner; a guy pushed to arson by means of a "lesion of the will"; an articulate and poised guy on trial for attack who, whereas accomplishing his personal safeguard, undergoes a profound character switch and turns into a wild and delusional "alter. " those individuals are no longer characters from a secret novelist's shiny mind's eye, yet particularly defendants who have been attempted on the previous Bailey, London's important legal courtroom, within the mid-nineteenth century.

Read e-book online Observations and Predictions of Eclipse Times by Early PDF

Eclipses have lengthy been obvious as vital celestial phenomena, even if as omens affecting the way forward for kingdoms, or as helpful astronomical occasions to assist in deriving crucial parameters for theories of the movement of the moon and sunlight. this can be the 1st booklet to assemble jointly all almost immediately recognized files of timed eclipse observations and predictions from antiquity to the time of the discovery of the telescope.

Extra info for Authority and Expertise in Ancient Scientific Culture

Sample text

21 For the Imperial period probably the richest development of the imagery of journeying and ascent comes in the pseudepigraphic Tablet of Cebes. 24 A number of significant claims and assumptions about the standing of philosophy and philosophers underlie and are underscored by these two sets of imagery. To figure philosophical activity as a path or an ascent, which all sensible human beings aim to follow, but philosophers cover faster or further than the rest, is to present it not as some optional pursuit, one choice of occupation among others, but as the one and only right course for a human being.

508a–9c is obvious. org/core. org/core/terms. 003 38 michael trapp There is no strong sense, however, in either of Plutarch’s essays of any kind of tension or struggle in the encounter of philosophical with political authority. Rather, it is suggested, in a way that implicitly flatters any ruler who happens to be reading, that as thinking beings, right-minded leaders will of course acknowledge the value and truth of philosophical discourse when exposed to it, and act accordingly. 36 Dio himself might just be thought an exception to the general pattern.

Eshleman 2012: 125–48. One of the arguments of her book as a whole is that we need to take more account of the overlaps between Greco-Roman and early Christian groups in their strategies of self-authorisation. Cf. Heath 2004: xvi, pointing out that Philostratus’ lack of interest in day-to-day training makes him very unreliable as a witness to mainstream rhetorical culture in the Roman Empire. For discussion of these terms, see Civiletti 2002: 576–7, with ref. 7 and Philostratus’ lack of interest in Hermogenes’ theoretical writings there.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.92 of 5 – based on 4 votes